Should you sell or rent your home when you get PCS orders from Fort Gordon?
Sell if the rent you could charge will not cover your full monthly cost of owning the home, especially when you will be away for fewer than three years or cannot keep a cash cushion. Rent if the rent covers the mortgage, taxes, insurance, repairs, and management with room to spare, and you have a plan for vacancies. The deciding step is to compare your actual net from a sale with a realistic landlord cash flow, and to check the Georgia and South Carolina property tax rules before you rent.
Your orders came through, the report date is on the calendar, and now the house you love has to become a decision. Do you sell it and take the equity, or hold on and rent it out from a few states away? I hear this from Fort Gordon families all the time, and the honest answer depends on a handful of numbers you can work out before you ever put a sign in the yard.
What selling actually puts in your pocket
Start with the sale, because it is the easier number to pin down. Your net is the sale price, minus your mortgage payoff, minus the cost of selling. Those costs include the real estate commission, closing attorney fees, any repairs or credits from the inspection, and the transfer tax.
The tax piece differs by side of the river. In Georgia, the Real Estate Transfer Tax is $1 per $1,000 of price, so about $320 on a $320,000 home. In South Carolina, the deed recording fee is $3.70 per $500, so about $2,368 on the same price. Both are customarily paid by the seller. My posts on closing costs when selling in Georgia and South Carolina and what the closing costs actually look like in Augusta walk through the rest of the line items.
If you want a quick planning range, many sellers should expect total selling costs in the range of 6% to 8% of the price once repairs and concessions are included. On a $320,000 home, that is roughly $19,200 to $25,600. Your own numbers will land somewhere in that range, and a net sheet built from your payoff tells you exactly where.
What renting actually costs you
Here is an illustration. Say the home would rent for $1,900 a month, and your monthly cost to keep it is $1,750 for principal, interest, taxes, and insurance.
- Property management: at 10% of rent, about $190 a month. Managing a house from another state is hard to do yourself.
- Vacancy: one empty month a year is about $158 a month averaged out.
- Repairs and upkeep: setting aside 1% of the home's value each year is about $267 a month on a $320,000 home.
Add those up and you are spending about $2,365 a month to collect $1,900, a shortfall near $465 a month, or about $5,600 a year. That is an illustration, not a quote. Plenty of houses do better, and some do worse, but it shows why "the rent covers the mortgage" is not the same as "the rental pays for itself."
You also have to remember where your housing allowance goes. Your BAH follows your new duty station, not your old house. For reference, 2026 BAH with dependents at Fort Gordon runs from about $1,890 for an E-5 to about $2,250 for an O-3, and your next location will have its own rate. You may be paying for a new place to live while still carrying the old one.
The tax rules that can change your answer
Federal capital gains. Normally you need to have lived in the home for two of the last five years to exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for a married couple filing jointly). Service members on qualified extended duty can ask to suspend that five-year window for up to 10 years. That can keep the exclusion available if you rent the home for several years before you sell. If you rent, though, any depreciation you claim (or were allowed to claim) is taxed when you sell. This is a question for your CPA, and it is worth asking before you sign a lease.
South Carolina property tax. If your home is in North Augusta, Aiken, or elsewhere in SC, your owner-occupied home is likely taxed at the 4% legal residence assessment ratio. Property that is not a legal residence is assessed at 6%, which raises the tax bill by about half. Whether a rented home keeps the 4% rate can depend on your domicile and on how your county assessor treats it, and federal law gives service members some protection on domicile. I would not guess. Call your county assessor and ask what happens to your classification before you rent.
Georgia homestead exemption. In Georgia, the homestead exemption requires that you occupy the home as your legal residence. Once you move out and rent it, expect to review your exemption with the Richmond or Columbia County tax office, since each county handles it separately.
What the local market says right now
The Freddie Mac 30-year average was 7.18% on November 5, 2026, up from 6.22% a year earlier. Active listings in the Augusta metro were up about 20% from a year ago in August, and Redfin put the median time on market in Augusta at 85 days in January. Higher rates and more inventory mean a home priced well and presented well still sells, but one that is overpriced sits. My post on how to tell if a home is overpriced shows the check I use.
Timing matters more when you have a report date. If you list late, you may end up carrying two housing costs at once, or leaving the house empty while the sale drags on. If you are weighing a price cut against an incentive to move it faster, my post on price cut or rate buydown works through that trade.
A simple way to decide
Answer these five questions honestly:
- Does the rent cover every cost? Count management, vacancy, and repairs, not just the mortgage.
- How long will you be away? Under three years often favors selling. Longer tours favor renting only when the numbers hold.
- Do you have a cash cushion? Three to six months of the home's costs is a sensible starting point.
- Is your equity thin? If a sale barely breaks even, renting may be a way to wait for a better price. If equity is strong, selling may free up real money for your next home.
- Do you want to be a landlord? Not every owner does, and that is a perfectly good reason to sell.
If you are a VA loan holder, ask your lender how keeping the home affects your remaining entitlement, since it may limit your next purchase. A VA loan can also be assumable by a qualified buyer, which can help if your rate is below today's.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I sell or rent my house when I PCS from Fort Gordon?
It depends on your numbers. Compare the net from a sale with the monthly cash flow of renting after management, vacancy, and repairs, and weigh how long you will be gone and how thin your equity is.
Can I still use the military capital gains exclusion if I rent the house?
Often yes. Service members on qualified extended duty can suspend the five-year test for up to 10 years, so you may still qualify for the exclusion if you sell later. Depreciation taken while renting is taxed, so check with a CPA first.
Does renting my North Augusta or Aiken home change my SC property tax?
It can. The 4% legal residence rate applies to a home that is your domicile, and other property is assessed at 6%. Ask your county assessor how your situation is classified before you rent.
How long does it take to sell a home in the Augusta area right now?
It varies by price, condition, and neighborhood. Redfin reported a median of 85 days on market in Augusta in January 2026. A home that is priced to the market and well presented usually does better than that.
Can I sell my home while I am already at my next duty station?
Yes, with planning. A signed power of attorney, a trusted local agent, and a closing attorney who can handle a remote or mobile closing make it workable.
Your next step
You do not have to guess. A sale net sheet and a rental cash flow side by side will usually make the answer clear in an afternoon.
Did your listing expire, or did you take your home off the market? Or are you trying to decide whether to list now or wait? Request a free Second Opinion Listing Review, and I'll show you what today's numbers say about your price, your timing, and what you would actually net at closing.
About Emily Hadden
Emily Hadden is Vice President and a REALTOR® with Blanchard and Calhoun Real Estate Co., licensed in Georgia and South Carolina. She brings 30+ years of advertising and sales experience to the work she has done since 2015: helping sellers price and position homes across Augusta, Evans, Martinez, Grovetown, North Augusta and Aiken.
Blanchard and Calhoun Real Estate Co. | Office: 706.863.8953 | Emily Hadden, Direct: 706.306.5264
601 Scott Nixon Memorial Drive, Augusta, GA 30907
Equal Housing Opportunity.
Payment, cost, and tax examples are illustrations, not quotes, and your numbers will differ. Market figures come from Freddie Mac, Realtor.com, and Redfin as cited, and BAH rates come from 2026 published tables. Rules on capital gains, depreciation, domicile, and property tax classification are general and change, so confirm them with a CPA, your county assessor, and a real estate attorney. This article is not tax, legal, or lending advice.
- A Fixer-Upper Could Be Your Path To Homeownership KCM Crew
- Planning To Sell in 2027? Start Prepping Now. KCM Crew
- The Housing Market Is on Solid Ground, Even with More Foreclosures KCM Crew
- Today's Market Could Be a Win for Veterans Looking To Buy a Home KCM Crew
- Low Rates or Lots of Leverage? Buyers Rarely Get Both. KCM Crew
- Selling Your Home? What You Should Know About Price Cuts vs. Rate Buydowns. KCM Crew
- What the Silver Tsunami Means if You’re Planning To Sell KCM Crew
- What Experts Forecast for Mortgage Rates and Home Prices in 2027 KCM Crew
- The Home Insurance Move That Could Save You $440 a Year KCM Crew
- Credit Scoring Is Changing: 3 Things Homebuyers Should Know KCM Crew
Search
Recent Posts
Homesale Proceeds Calculator
KCM
Current Mortgage Rates
Share My QR |
|
Success!


